Principles from Sir Winston Churchill
How You Reason with a Tiger When Your Head is in its Mouth
Estimated reading time (5 minutes)
Happy Friday, everyone.
On Principles Friday, I share one principle that can help you in your life or business, one thought-provoking question, and one call to action toward that principle.
Principle of the Week
"It is not enough that we do our best; sometimes we must do what is required."— Sir Winston Churchill
One of the most remarkable stories that exemplifies Churchill's principle lies in the Dunkirk Evacuation during World War II.
The Situation: In May 1940, British and Allied forces found themselves trapped on the Dunkirk beaches, surrounded by the advancing German army. Evacuation seemed impossible, with limited resources and the Luftwaffe dominating the skies.
Doing One's Best Would Not Suffice: The official plan, Operation Dynamo, aimed to evacuate 45,000 troops. Doing their best with available resources, the Royal Navy and civilian boats were expected to achieve this within a week. However, Churchill knew "doing their best" wouldn't cut it. Britain faced annihilation if they lost these troops.
What Was Required? Churchill's leadership transcended simply "doing the best." He demanded the "impossible." He:
Issued Operation Dynamo's "miracle" order: He pushed for evacuating 338,000 men, not 45,000, setting an audacious goal.
Mobilized an armada: He rallied every available vessel, from fishing boats to pleasure yachts, transforming the civilian fleet into a lifeline.
Inspired the nation: He delivered a historic speech, calling upon "the little ships" and the spirit of the British people to rise to the occasion.
The Outcome: Over eight days, under constant aerial bombardment, over 860 vessels ferried back 338,226 troops, defying expectations and achieving a miracle. This success not only saved the British Expeditionary Force but also preserved the core of its fighting spirit, crucial for the war's eventual outcome.
Beyond Doing One's Best: This story showcases Churchill's leadership in action. He understood that in critical situations, simply doing your best might not be enough. True leadership demands recognizing what's "required," even if it seems impossible, and then inspiring and mobilizing others to achieve it. The Dunkirk Evacuation serves as a powerful testament to the impact of "doing what is required," not just settling for "doing your best."
Small ask: 👉 If you enjoy reading this post, feel free to share it with friends! Or feel free to click the ❤️ button on this post so more people can discover it on Substack 🙏
Question to Ponder
Take your time to remember when you had a difficult problem to overcome. What effort did you put into solving it? Did you do what is best or what is required? Was the outcome satisfactory?
Call to Action
While no single, universally accepted framework directly mirrors Churchill's "doing what's required" principle, one stands out in your work context. The High-Performance Organizations (HPO) Framework, developed by Robert Kaplan and David Norton, emphasizes exceeding expectations and continuous improvement. It aligns strategy, people, and processes to achieve ambitious goals beyond typical performance levels. The core idea is to set stretch goals that demand more than "doing your best" and foster a culture of constant innovation and improvement.
Using its five key characteristics: Management Quality, Openness/Action Orientation, Long-Term Orientation, Continuous Improvement/Renewal, and Quality of Employees, let's explore how each contributes to tackling seemingly impossible problems:
1. Management Quality:
Empowerment: Delegate decision-making to those closest to the problem. Trust their expertise and ability to find creative solutions. Churchill delegated significant authority to military commanders like Alan Brooke and Bernard Montgomery, trusting their expertise and allowing them to adapt strategies.
Transparency: Share information openly and encourage questioning. Foster an environment where ideas flow freely, even if they challenge the status quo. Churchill held regular War Cabinet meetings where information was shared openly, encouraging debate and critical thinking. He even addressed the nation directly in his famous speeches, keeping them informed and engaged.
Accountability: Set clear goals and hold yourself and others accountable for progress, even if incremental. Celebrate small wins and learn from setbacks.
2. Openness/Action Orientation:
External Benchmarking: Look outside your industry for solutions to similar problems. Learn from their successes and failures. Churchill studied historical and contemporary military campaigns, drawing inspiration and strategies from past successes and failures. He also closely observed the tactics of his enemies, adapting his approach accordingly.
Collaboration: Bring diverse perspectives together. Form cross-functional teams with individuals from different departments and backgrounds. Churchill forged strong alliances with leaders like Roosevelt and Stalin, uniting resources and strategies against a common enemy. He valued diverse perspectives and sought counsel from advisors with different backgrounds and expertise.
Experimentation: Embrace a "test and learn" mentality. Pilot small-scale solutions and iterate based on results. Don't be afraid to fail; view it as a learning opportunity. Churchill famously supported unconventional ideas like the development of radar and the bombing of German dams. He embraced calculated risks and encouraged innovation to gain an edge.
3. Long-Term Orientation:
Big Picture Focus: Don't get bogged down in the immediate challenge. Align your solution with your long-term vision and goals. Churchill never lost sight of the war's ultimate goal – defeating Nazi Germany and preserving democracy.
Sustainability: Consider the long-term impact of your solution. Is it financially, environmentally, and socially sustainable?
Resilience: Build in buffers and contingency plans to anticipate and adapt to changing circumstances. Churchill's unwavering resolve and determination in the face of adversity symbolized national resilience. He rallied the British people after Dunkirk and continued fighting even when victory seemed impossible.
4. Continuous Improvement/Renewal:
Learning: Foster a culture of continuous learning. Encourage training, knowledge sharing, and reflection on successes and failures.
Innovation: Encourage creative problem-solving and out-of-the-box thinking. Reward innovative solutions, even if they seem unconventional.
Process Refinement: Regularly review and improve your processes to identify and eliminate inefficiencies.
5. Quality of Employees:
Talent Acquisition: Recruit and retain high-performing individuals with diverse skills and perspectives. Invest in their development and well-being. Churchill surrounded himself with skilled advisors and military leaders, recognizing their talents and expertise. He recruited individuals from diverse backgrounds, valuing different perspectives and experiences.
Motivation: Create a motivating work environment that fosters engagement and ownership. Recognize and reward achievements.
Teamwork: Build strong, collaborative teams where individuals support and learn from each other. Encourage open communication and conflict resolution.
Video of the Week
"You Cannot Reason with a Tiger When Your Head Is in Its Mouth" is a powerful quote from Sir Winston Churchill.
If you want to learn more principles, I interview founders on my podcast, The First 100, where they share how they acquired their first 100 paying customers. This week:
Episode 125 - The First 100 with Matthew Grant, a partner at Instech
Episode 126 - The First 100 with Steven Bartel, co-founder of Gem
And that’s a wrap for now!
Thank you for giving your attention and checking this edition out.
If you enjoyed this edition, it would MEAN A LOT to me if you could take a few seconds and help me by sharing this article with your friends.
If you are not a subscriber, sign up and join others who receive it directly in their inbox weekly.